Mobile Bible School – Thesis Defense Evaluation Rubric

Total Score: 100 points

---

A. WRITTEN THESIS QUALITY — 50 points

1. Biblical Foundation & Theological Accuracy — 15 pts

• Uses Scripture correctly (preferably KJV)
• Demonstrates sound doctrine (non-Calvinist/Arminian bias if Biblicist)
• Shows deep theological reflection
  Excellent (13–15) | Good (10–12) | Fair (7–9) | Poor (0–6)

2. Clarity of Research Problem & Purpose — 10 pts

• Problem clearly identified
• Purpose well-aligned with topic
• Research questions/objectives are focused
  Excellent (9–10) | Good (7–8) | Fair (5–6) | Poor (0–4)

3. Literature Review & Use of Sources — 10 pts

• Uses credible theological, biblical, and academic sources
• Shows understanding of previous scholarship
• Correct citations and integration
  Excellent (9–10) | Good (7–8) | Fair (5–6) | Poor (0–4)

4. Structure, Organization & Writing Quality — 10 pts

• Logical flow
• Clear introduction, body, and conclusion
• Grammar, coherence, transitions
  Excellent (9–10) | Good (7–8) | Fair (5–6) | Poor (0–4)

5. Practical Ministry Application — 5 pts

• Work is useful for the church/ministry
• Shows real-life pastoral or leadership relevance
  Excellent (5) | Good (4) | Fair (3) | Poor (0–2)

---

B. ORAL DEFENSE PERFORMANCE — 40 points

1. Presentation Delivery — 10 pts

• Clear, confident, well-paced
• Good eye contact and voice projection
  Excellent (9–10) | Good (7–8) | Fair (5–6) | Poor (0–4)

2. Mastery of Content — 10 pts

• Shows deep understanding of thesis
• Can explain concepts without reading
  Excellent (9–10) | Good (7–8) | Fair (5–6) | Poor (0–4)

3. Biblical & Theological Defense — 10 pts

• Answers questions using Scripture
• Defends theological position with clarity
  Excellent (9–10) | Good (7–8) | Fair (5–6) | Poor (0–4)

4. Response to Panel Questions — 10 pts

• Answers directly and intelligently
• Shows humility and good attitude
• Responds calmly under pressure
  Excellent (9–10) | Good (7–8) | Fair (5–6) | Poor (0–4)

---

C. ORIGINALITY & MINISTRY IMPACT — 10 points

1. Creativity & Contribution — 5 pts

• Presents fresh insights
• Shows personal conviction and originality
  Excellent (5) | Good (4) | Fair (3) | Poor (0–2)

2. Kingdom & Church Value — 5 pts

• Thesis is beneficial for discipleship, evangelism, leadership, or worship
  Excellent (5) | Good (4) | Fair (3) | Poor (0–2)

---

GRADE INTERPRETATION

• 95–100 = Outstanding (With High Distinction)
• 90–94 = Excellent (Distinction)
• 85–89 = Very Good
• 80–84 = Good
• 75–79 = Satisfactory / Passed
• Below 75 = Needs Revision / Failed